treehouse : what would you like to learn today?
Web Design Web Development iOS Development

Logo critique / feedback please

  • Hey there,

    i actually redesign my website and want to use also a new logo for it.

    My name is jan mense and my name will allways be shown next to the logo!

    First one:
    Klick me

    Second:
    Klick me

    Please give me some feedback, thanks!
  • I'm interested in the first one although I think you need to create some unique grain on the icon. Making different parts more grainy would move the eye around a bit better. The second one has a motorola vibe, so it's too familiar for me.

    I hope this helps.
  • I agree, my immediate impression was that the first logo was a little more original.
  • It looks cool but it's not legible to see a J.
  • I like the first one.

    If you can somehow integrate a more vivid j and m merged into a single element in the center logo, I think it would "pop" a little more for me.

    Nice work.
  • Hey, thanks!

    i tried to get the J into my logo and also tried a sans-serif font, i think it works better now, what do you think?

    Klick me
  • I like the very first one.

    the 2nd one reminds me of a 37 signals app a little to much.

    I think with the way the first one is lined up above the M in your name it seems to work.

    my 2 cents
  • got another idea

    Klick me
  • I think #1 takes the cake..

    Colour, values, and texture aside, it has a very solid and symmetrical composition.

    #1 also has the strongest typography. Having the two font weights really helps me realize that Jan Mense is your name, rather than Janmense acting as one word. I think the second line of text looks nicer in a lighter weight instead of how its bolded in #2.

    Also if you're really set on working in your J to the logo, maybe something (roughly) along the lines of this ? http://i.min.us/igBp1BOKdXNr1.jpg

    Overall I think you nailed it though - good work.

    - Max